Jerry Stiller’s Chicken Soup With Kreplach

One night I said to Mr Rathbone over, and over and over again, “This is the funniest film I ever saw” about The Independent starring Jerry Stiller.

The next day I could remember nothing about it.  Zilch.  Nada.  So we resolved to watch it again on “Stiller Saturday”, to celebrate the completion of test cooking for the Murder, She Cooked book (little did I know then, that there was still one recipe to go!).

Still time to enter – skip over here!

For yes, my favourite comedian, from my favourite funny film (even though I couldn’t remember a single moment from it) is in an episode of Murder, She Wrote.

This, by the way, is from a series of fake “trading cards” featuring Murder, She Wrote co-stars which really made me chuckle.  You can find them here… JasonToon, I salute you.  I love that people spend their time on flights of fancy like this, but admit, I was somewhat crestfallen to discover something recently. My chum Kevin Geddes wrote the fabulous Keep Calm and Fanny On, a biography of Fanny Cradock.

let me know that this too is a fake.

I’ve been trying to find a copy of that for years!  I hereby salute you too, Andrew-Mark Thompson!

But back to Jerry Stiller.  Me and Mr R planned out a whole day of Stiller fabulousness. A morning session of the Murder, She Wrote featuring Jerry, with The Independent planned as our evening movie.

Mr R bought some episodes of Seinfeld (which he has tried to convince me to watch before) where Jerry plays Frank Constanza.

I laughed out loud only ONCE during the two Seinfelds (and I think it was when someone threw a tennis ball at Kramer) but probably about 90 times during The Independent.  So I can confirm, it is the funniest film I ever saw.  But caveat.  I was VERY drunk.

The chicken soup with kreplach was really time consuming but I was madly in love with my kreplach.

Neither myself nor Mr R had never heard the word kreplach before encountering Jerry’s recipe and Mr R called them many things throughout the day including kersplatch, kerfuffles, kreplani, kracklepp and kerfunkels.

This was labour-intensive but a lot of fun.  I was VERY proud of my kreplach even though they were a bit sturdy.

So here’s Jerry’s recipe.  It is lots of fun to make.

10 responses

  1. I love Jerry Stiller in Seinfield but I don’t know this movie. But I adore Chicken Soup or as its otherwise known ‘Jewish Penicillin’ After a trying day in old LA many years ago and not wanting to eat a plastic salad in the hotel restaurant I ventured out and found a fantastic old Jewish deli on Pico Blvd. Even called it ‘Jewish Penicillin’ on the menu, was just what I needed as was the Salf beef that followed.

  2. I love Jerry Stiller in Seinfield but I don’t know this movie. But I adore Chicken Soup or as its otherwise known ‘Jewish Penicillin’ After a trying day in old LA many years ago and not wanting to eat a plastic salad in the hotel restaurant I ventured out and found a fantastic old Jewish deli on Pico Blvd. Even called it ‘Jewish Penicillin’ on the menu, was just what I needed as was the Salf beef that followed.

  3. I had a salt beef sandwich yesterday – yum! Admittedly it was from M&S and not a proper Jewish deli but it was still delicious! Jx

  4. I had a salt beef sandwich yesterday – yum! Admittedly it was from M&S and not a proper Jewish deli but it was still delicious! Jx

  5. Ha ! Me too, from the Tesco Express in Whitechapel ! No time to get to the Bagel bake in Brick lane ! But not at all bad for all that !

  6. Ha ! Me too, from the Tesco Express in Whitechapel ! No time to get to the Bagel bake in Brick lane ! But not at all bad for all that !

  7. Jerry Stiller was the real, shining star of ‘King of Queens’, a sit-com that was on here for years. A fat dumb guy, and skinny shrewish wife – Jerry Stiller was her father who lived with them. Every time he appeared, as he lived in his own little world, he was very awkward and very hilarious.

  8. Jerry Stiller was the real, shining star of ‘King of Queens’, a sit-com that was on here for years. A fat dumb guy, and skinny shrewish wife – Jerry Stiller was her father who lived with them. Every time he appeared, as he lived in his own little world, he was very awkward and very hilarious.

  9. SALLY! You have reminded me of something I’d forgotten about. I used to love King of Queens! They showed it here in the UK too. Around the same time as another American show I liked, Everybody Loves Raymond. I’m going to see if I can find either of those on a streaming service!

  10. SALLY! You have reminded me of something I’d forgotten about. I used to love King of Queens! They showed it here in the UK too. Around the same time as another American show I liked, Everybody Loves Raymond. I’m going to see if I can find either of those on a streaming service!

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Cooking The Detectives is a bite-sized guide to all the best TV cop shows - click on image for more details.

Recipes from the kitchen of Angela Lansbury and many of her fabulous co-stars - click on image for more details.

Recipes from the kitchen of Peter Falk and many of his fabulous co-stars - click on image for more details.

Supper with the Stars: With your host Vincent Price - click on image for more details.

Cooking With Joan Crawford - 2023 reissue with extra recipes from Joan's kitchen - click on image for more info.

Vera Haiku - every episode of the iconic TV detective show distilled into seventeen syllables - click on image for more info.

Monthly movie star menus direct to your inbox - just click on the image and enter your email address.

Monthly Vera Haiku direct to your inbox

Cooking Vincent Price’s Goulash with Nathalie for the British Film Institute

Silver Screen Suppers on Market Kitchen

Silver Screen Suppers Archive

The Stars

BMC logoBuy me a coffee

Monthly movie star menus direct to your inbox

You have Successfully Subscribed!