Recipe of the Month – Janet Gaynor’s Ice Box Cookies

If I were a more organised person I would ALWAYS have a batch of Janet’s cookie dough lying resplendent in my freezer for when unexpected guests pop round for a cup of tea.  The thing I love about this recipe is that you make it a day before you need it, pop it in your ice box and slice and bake it next day – or whenever you fancy some cookies.

Here is the latest batch, lying dormant in the freezer.

And here are some I made earlier:

The recipe is here if you are looking in September 2013 – changes every month!

4 responses

  1. Wow these are SO similar to my great-grandma’s ice-box cookies. I stayed with her all the time as a little kid and we baked something almost every day. She usually replaced the walnuts with pecans from her own trees. She still picks and shells some pecans for me every year as part of my Christmas present.

    I really enjoy Janet Gaynor movies. I think Sunrise, Sunny Side Up, and The Young in Heart (and, of course, A Star is Born) are my favorites so far.

    1. Ah that is so lovely! Pecans! From trees! I don’t think we have pecan trees over here, but my folks have a walnut tree in their garden so I often get a nice little bag of these when I go and visit.

      I haven’t seen many Janet Gaynor movies but I do love Sunrise. She is so cute!

  2. Wow these are SO similar to my great-grandma’s ice-box cookies. I stayed with her all the time as a little kid and we baked something almost every day. She usually replaced the walnuts with pecans from her own trees. She still picks and shells some pecans for me every year as part of my Christmas present.

    I really enjoy Janet Gaynor movies. I think Sunrise, Sunny Side Up, and The Young in Heart (and, of course, A Star is Born) are my favorites so far.

    1. Ah that is so lovely! Pecans! From trees! I don’t think we have pecan trees over here, but my folks have a walnut tree in their garden so I often get a nice little bag of these when I go and visit.

      I haven’t seen many Janet Gaynor movies but I do love Sunrise. She is so cute!

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Cooking The Detectives is a bite-sized guide to all the best TV cop shows - click on image for more details.

Recipes from the kitchen of Angela Lansbury and many of her fabulous co-stars - click on image for more details.

Recipes from the kitchen of Peter Falk and many of his fabulous co-stars - click on image for more details.

Supper with the Stars: With your host Vincent Price - click on image for more details.

Cooking With Joan Crawford - 2023 reissue with extra recipes from Joan's kitchen - click on image for more info.

Vera Haiku - every episode of the iconic TV detective show distilled into seventeen syllables - click on image for more info.

Monthly movie star menus direct to your inbox - just click on the image and enter your email address.

Monthly Vera Haiku direct to your inbox

Cooking Vincent Price’s Goulash with Nathalie for the British Film Institute

Silver Screen Suppers on Market Kitchen

Silver Screen Suppers Archive

The Stars

BMC logoBuy me a coffee

Monthly movie star menus direct to your inbox

You have Successfully Subscribed!